Defendant accepts liability just before trial, argues unnecessary surgery and inflated lien cost.
The Case
- Case Name: Carrizoza v. Villanueva, et al.
- Court and Case Number: Fresno County Superior Court / 24CECG01530
- Date of Verdict or Judgment: Friday, July 24, 2026
- Date Action was Filed: Monday, April 08, 2024
- Type of Case: Vehicles - Auto vs. Auto
- Judge or Arbitrator(s): Hon. Jonathan Skiles
- Plaintiffs:
Gaspar Carrizoza, 37Alexa F. (Minor)
- Defendants:
Francisco VillanuevaSundip Singh Sangha
- Type of Result: Jury Verdict
The Result
- Gross Verdict or Award: $2,746,478.72
- Award as to each Defendant:
Judgment against both defendants; stipulated that Sangha was vicariously liable for VIllanueva (in course and scope).
- Contributory/Comparative Negligence: None
- Economic Damages:
Past and future medical expenses; past lost wages.
- Jury Polls: 12-0, on all questions
The Attorneys
- Attorney for the Plaintiff:
Bonakdar Law Firm by Roger Bonakdar and R. Marc Stamper, Fresno.
- Attorney for the Defendant:
Higgs, Fletcher & Mack LLP by Nicholas Brauns and Richard Lozano, San Diego.
The Experts
- Plaintiff’s Medical Experts:
Dr. Ali Najafi
- Plaintiff’s Medical Expert(s):
Ali Najafi, M.D., neurosurgery. (Treating physician.)
- Defendant's Medical Expert(s):
Michael Rudin, M.D., ortho-neurosurgery.
Nancy Fraser Michalski, RN BSN, medical damages and billing.
Facts and Background
- Facts and Background:
Plaintiff G. Carrizoza was traveling on "Old 41" (a stretch of Highway 41, in the county of Fresno) southbound at approximately 60 miles per hour, with her then-three-year-old daughter (and also plaintiff) Alexa.
Defendant Villanueva (who was working for defendant Sundip Singh Sangha dba Triple S Farms), attempted to traverse from east to west across Old 41 on Nebraska Avenue, pulling out directly in front of plaintiffs, causing plaintiffs to "T-bone" Villanueva.
Airbags deployed, both vehicles were totaled. CHP reported to the scene and placed Villanueva at fault.
- Plaintiff's Contentions:
That defendant driver was in the course and scope of his employment with defendant Sundip Singh Sangha. That he was fully liable for the accident.
- Defendant's Contentions:
Defendants admitted liability approximately 20 days prior to trial. At all times defendants maintained that the cervical injury/disc bulges were degenerative and not caused by the accident; denying the medical necessity or reasonableness of the ESIs and the two-level discectomy and fusion.
-
Defendant's medical expert noted the MRIs did not demonstrate acute disc injuries, and took the position that the numbness and tingling in the neck and arms which led to plaintiff's surgical recommendation did not begin until several months after the accident.
Defendants' billing expert testified plaintiff’s claimed past and future specials were excessive, and noted the reimbursement rate for the services in the Fresno community was roughly 30% of those billed on a lien-basis by plaintiff's providers.
Defense noted that plaintiff built a home through Habitat for Humanity in connection with 175 “sweat equity” hours, performing many similar movements to those which she testified caused her neck pain; they presented photos and testimony about construction work plaintiff did (six months to a year after collision), including showing photographs of plaintiff hanging sheet rock, digging, and carrying wood for framing.
Defendants also pointed out a 1.5 year gap in medical treatment prior to surgery.
-
Injuries and Other Damages
- Physical Injuries claimed by Plaintiff:
Cervical injury, resulting in need for discectomy and fusion. Carrizoza was transported to hospital by ambulance. She underwent some initial conservative (chiropractic) care, and MRIs were performed to determine the cause of neck pain and radiating pain, numbness and tingling in her extremities. The MRIs revealed spinal cord compression and disc bulges. She was referred to a specialist (neurosurgeon), with whom she would treat for the next two to three years.
Plaintiff underwent two rounds of cervical ESIs and, because her symptoms persisted, was recommended to undergo a two-level discectomy and fusion. Approximately 2.6 years after the recommendation was made, plaintiff underwent the surgery. The surgery was a success and reduced plaintiff's pain by 70% and resolved the extremity numbness.
Note that plaintiff's medical expert was the treating neurosurgeon.
Special Damages
- Special Damages Claimed - Past Medical: $347,466.72
- Special Damages Claimed - Future Medical: $315,354.72
- Special Damages Claimed - Past Lost Earnings: $5,350
Additional Notes
Verdict: $2,735,316.72 for Carrizoza; $11,162 for the minor, Alexa.
Plaintiff Carrizoza served a 998 in December of 2025 for $890,000, which was rejected.
Defendants' highest 998 to Carrizoza (less than 30 days before trial): $222,500.
Defendants' 998 to minor Alexa: $2,500.
Defendants carried a $1,000,000 per occurrence policy limit. Plaintiffs made a policy limits demand that was rejected.
Insurer: Kemper Commercial