Skip to main content

Terminated after his probationary period by the same supervisor who hired him. 

 

The Case

  • Case Name: Jesus Medina v. Newhall School District
  • Court and Case Number: Los Angeles Superior Court / 24STCV13540
  • Date of Verdict or Judgment: Tuesday, August 11, 2026
  • Date Action was Filed: Thursday, May 30, 2024
  • Type of Case: Employment
  • Judge or Arbitrator(s): Hon. Alexander Giza
  • Plaintiffs:
    Jesus Medina
  • Defendants:
    Newhall School District
  • Type of Result: Jury Verdict

The Result

  • Gross Verdict or Award: Defense verdict
  • Jury Polls: Unanimous for defendant

The Attorneys

  • Attorney for the Plaintiff:

    Advantage Advocates, PC by Amy Ramsey, Pasadena.

    Tom Wheeler Law, APC by Thomas Wheeler, Glendale.

  • Attorney for the Defendant:

    Kessel & Megrabyan by Armineh Megrabyan and Martha Cohen, Burbank.

The Experts

  • Defendant's Technical Expert(s):

    Jon Sand, Ed.D., school personnel matters.

Facts and Background

  • Facts and Background:

    Plaintiff was hired by the Newhall School District at age 71 as a substitute custodian. A year later, when he was 72, his supervisor encouraged him to apply to become a night custodian. When he applied for the position, he was hired  as a night custodian. Under District policy, the probation period is six months, and probationary custodians receive three-month and five-month performance evaluations. These evaluations are a tool for deciding whether an employee is retained and made permanent, along with the supervisor’s observation of the employee’s performance during the probationary period.

    Plaintiff's three-month evaluation was proficient in every category; his five-month evaluation was proficient overall, with a single "basic" rating in quantity of work, and a comment from the supervisor that he wanted to see improvement in quality of work and “to make sure that everything is being completed on a daily basis and areas aren’t being left unclean. Please make sure that you are being very thorough when cleaning restrooms.”

    One day before he would have completed his six-month probationary period and obtained permanent status, the District terminated him. He was the oldest person the District had ever hired into the custodian position and the only probationary custodian terminated during the relevant period.

    Mr. Medina brought a single cause of action for age discrimination under the FEHA.

  • Plaintiff's Contentions:

    Plaintiff contended that the District's stated performance reasons were pretextual and that his age was a substantial motivating reason for the termination.

    He relied on circumstantial evidence: strong written evaluations; comparator custodians who performed the same or worse yet were retained, all significantly younger; the District's practice of hiring custodians young and letting them "age in place"; shifting and contradictory explanations for the termination (including an EDD letter disparaging his performance that HR admitted had no basis, contradicted by a glowing recommendation letter the decision-maker wrote a week after the termination); the timing of the termination one day before permanency; and impeachment of the District's witnesses on the limited universe of complaints actually relied upon.

  • Defendant's Contentions:

    The District contended that plaintiff was terminated for legitimate, non-discriminatory performance reasons – principally complaints about the cleanliness of a restroom on his route and his alleged failure to follow assigned duties – and that age played no role.

    That a couple of weeks after the five–month evaluation, the supervisor received multiple complaints and a report from the assistant director of the facilities and maintenance, that the restroom in question was found unclean again in the morning after plaintiff was supposed to have cleaned it the night before and locked the door. The supervisor, believing the problem of inconstant restroom cleaning was continuing instead of improving, made the decision to release plaintiff for failure to pass probation. The release was without cause, as is customary when releasing probationary employees, who are at-will. 

    It argued that the same supervisor who hired plaintiff at 71 years old, encouraged him to apply for the night custodian job, and then promoted him at 72 years of age, would not have been motivated by age, that health-and-safety concerns drove the decision, and that plaintiff's performance declined between his three- and five-month evaluations and the problem of inconsistent cleaning of the restroom continued after the five-month evaluation as well. The school’s principal and day custodian also confirmed the restroom was being left uncleaned by plaintiff, and that they had filed multiple complaints to the supervisor and other facilities department staff.

Demands and Offers

  • Plaintiff §998 Demand: $199,000
  • Defendant §998 Offer: $100,001

Subscribe Today
Access All the Case Details Behind Every Verdict

JuryVerdictAlert.com provides limited case details for public viewing so you can see the scope of our coverage. However, access to complete case summaries, full fact patterns, damages breakdowns, attorney and expert information, and advanced search features is reserved for subscribers.

To review the full version of each verdict in our database you’ll need an active subscription to JuryVerdictAlert.com.